Reviews & Columns
Reviews
DVD
TV on DVD
Blu-ray
4K UHD
International DVDs
In Theaters
Reviews by Studio

Features
Collector Series DVDs
Easter Egg Database
Interviews
Feature Articles

Columns
Anime Talk
DVD Savant
Horror DVDs
The M.O.D. Squad
Art House
HD Talk
Silent DVD

discussion forum
DVD Talk Forum

Columns




In Living Color: Season 2

Fox // Unrated // September 28, 2004
List Price: $49.98 [Buy now and save at Amazon]

Review by Robert Spuhler | posted November 9, 2004 | E-mail the Author
Comparing In Living Color to a show like Saturday Night Live is unfair. The latter has to fill 90 minutes every week, has the restrictions of NBC (as opposed to the free-wheeling mentality of the early stages of Fox) and carries around the constant comparisons to its brilliant past.

But there's no question in my mind that In Living Color was funnier than most SNL casts, with the possible exceptions of the originals and the Carvey/Myers/Hartman era.

In Living Color Season 2 irons out some of the kinks from the first season, eliminates some of the clunker sketches, and delivers 24 consistently-funny episodes (26, if including the best-of editions). It is almost 10 hours of top-notch comedy that has managed to stay fresh over time.

Led by Keenan Ivory Wayans, his very funny family members, and stars-in-training such as Tommy Davidson, David Alan Grier and Jim (then "James") Carrey, In Living Color Season 2 sees the invention and development of some of the funniest characters in sketch comedy history:

Homey D. Clown: Damon Wayans is the ghetto clown known more for abusing children than balloon animals. Get ready for more of Homey: A full-length feature is in the works for 2005.

Tom and Tom Brothers: The Brothers Brothers, the whitest black men on television, interview ex-cons and do commercials for Arizona tourism after the state voted against a Martin Luther King holiday.

HandiMan: The character that probably sentenced Damon Wayans to eternity in hell. HandiMan is the first-ever handicapped superhero, complete with a blue outfit and a handicap symbol on the chest.

Vera de Milo: Jim Carrey is a steroid-popping female bodybuilder. As ridiculous as it sounds.

Because of the length of each episode (22 minutes, minus musical guests), most sketches involve a recurring character. Each actor on the show seems to have three or four ready, whether it be one of the ones above, the Jamaican family that shares tens of jobs, the Homeboy Shopping Network, the Head Detective … and because there are so many, there's enough rotation that any individual character can't wear out his/her welcome.

Damon Wayans was the breakout star of the second season. His fingerprints are all over each episode, and his characters ended up gaining the most traction. He was also the first to leave the show for "superstardom," and while some identify the end of the show's good run to when Keenan pulled out, the day Damon's name stopped showing up in the credits was the day that many of the show's best characters died.

Not every sketch revolved around set characters, though, and even those manage to hold up more than a decade later. Some highlights:

Spike's Joint: Spike Lee (Tommy Davidson) opens his own store, featuring his own shoes (Spikes, pronounced "Spike-Ees," with a suspiciously-familiar logo) and free copies of "School Daze" with purchase that no one seems to want. Cameo by Rosie Perez.

The Wheel: Keenan Ivory Wayans sets out to explain to us how In Living Color decides what group of people to make fun of each week, with help of a giant wheel. "White folks" makes up 95 percent of the possibilities.

The Arsenio Hall of Justice: Arsenio Hall prosecutes a case. "These people over here, these are the people too stupid to get out of jury duty." Look for the cameo from SNL alum Ellen Cleghorn.

The DVD

Video:

In Living Color Season 2 holds up pretty well for a show from the early 90s. The colors are a little muted, but there's no artifacts or other digital flaws.

Audio:

The stereo 2.0 track is about all that could be expected for a television release. As a fan of that era's hip-hop, it's disappointing to hear some of the musical performances in such a flat environment, but the bulk of the dialogue is easy to understand and audience applause isn't overwhelming.

Extras:

There are selected commentary tracks for some sketches from writers Kim Bass and Buddy Sheffield. With all due respect to the duo, they are hardly the names fans would be wanted to hear. The commentaries themselves are light on actual information; the two mostly talk about how much fun they had and how talented the people who worked on the show are.

There are also three featurettes: An overview of season two (mainly just highlights), Notorious ILC: Characters and Appreciating In Living Color. All three featurettes suffer a bit from spotty participation from the main players – David Alan Grier and Tommy Davidson are the biggest names from the cast to talk about the show.

Final Thoughts:

It's hard to imagine any sketch comedy show again capturing this kind of talent. In Living Color billed itself as a racially diverse exercise, kind of a balance to the usually-lilywhite Saturday Night Live. But more important than the demographic appeal was that the show was flat out funny – to everybody. In Living Color Season 2 does a good job of capturing that and reminding us exactly what sketch comedy looks like at its best.

Buy from Amazon.com

C O N T E N T

V I D E O

A U D I O

E X T R A S

R E P L A Y

A D V I C E
Highly Recommended

E - M A I L
this review to a friend
Popular Reviews

Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links